Testimonials

Write Your Own

Schedule Appointment

I stumbled upon this fantastic business when I was shopping at the farmers market that occurs in the same area. I immediately knew this was the perfect place to purchase an engagement ring. Not to discredit the big box jewelry stores, but I strive for uniqueness and a more personal ... interaction. Whereas the stores you see in the mall I feel like are more transactional. I went here about a month or two ago to look around and Annie was absolutely patient with me because I had no idea what I was doing. That same day, I found what I wanted. Annie went above and beyond to achieve what I was drafting in my head and made it come to life within a few weeks! Now I haven’t picked up the ring yet, but I was able to do a virtual appointment to see it (due to the Covid-19) with Bob and it looks absolutely stunning! Words can’t express how much I appreciate the customer service they have given, especially during these unprecedented times. Even though I haven’t seen the ring in person yet, these few outstanding interactions have instilled so much trust that I just know it’s perfect. I will definitely go here for most to all of my jewelry needs! Read More
  • - Christina Santiago
  • At: Columbus
  • On: April 28, 2020
Worthington Jewelers took the scary experience of breaking my engagement ring and made it better almost instantly. Their staff was knowledgeable, friendly, and so helpful. The repair cost was incredibly reasonable and knowing that they do their repairs in-house set my mind at ease. The turnaround time was even faster ... than expected and their repair work is flawless. I’ll absolutely be coming back for any future repair or jewelry needs. Read More
My experience with Worthington Jewelers was absolutely phenomenal. They were able to fix my mom's ring and make it look better than ever. Their turn-around time for repairs was incredibly fast, the work performed was impeccable and their customer service was top-notch. I would recommend Worthington Jewelers to anyone in ... search of a place to purchase jewelry, or have jewelry repaired! Such an incredible company!! Read More
  • - Katelyn Pollock
  • At: Columbus
  • On: March 4, 2020
I recently worked with Worthington Jewelers on having two rings resized, I was really nervous about choosing the right jewelry store as the rings are really important to me. Due to a constant fluctuation in my hand size from heart issues I needed a jeweler who could help me figure ... figure out the right size for my rings. Kathryn was SO sweet to me, really took her time having me try different sizes and coming up with a game plan on what would work best. I was also very impressed with their process on service tickets to ensure everyone is clear on what you left with them. My rings were done well before the already quick turnaround time they gave me and my goodness, they looked beautiful! You could not even tell that they had been altered! They also fit fantastically! Everyone in there is so kind and while their store and jewelry is beautiful, they don't have an arrogance about them that makes you uncomfortable. You feel so welcomed, I'm a lifelong customer! Read More
Always a pleasure getting new jewelry or jewelry repaired at Worthington Jewelers. Service is done quickly and at a fair price. I have had the prongs replaced on 2 different rings and watch batteries replaced. They also have estate jewelry for sale at a bargain! Read More
I purchased some rings overseas in the Virgin islands and they were not of good quality when it came to holding the gems so I took them to Worthington Jewelers. they did a fantastic job in securing the gems as well as cleaning the rings and bringing them back to ... the finest quality! I totally would recommend Worthington Jewelers to everyone! Read More
  • - Suzanne MacDonald
  • At: Columbus
  • On: Jan. 14, 2020
Tabitha was absolutely awesome! Bought an engagement ring here and she made the process painless and easy. We shopped around at some other jewelry stores, and nobody knew more about what they had than Tabitha. I highly recommend this store to anybody in the market for a diamond.
Eric was amazingly helpful. As mother of the bride I was uncertain as to what I wanted/needed. He helped me work in budget to find a beautiful pearl and diamond necklace. There selection was fantastic and the whole experience was truly 5 star!
  • - Deborah Pentenburg
  • At: Columbus
  • On: Dec. 17, 2019
Devon, Bob & Theresa are awesome! They care so much about their customers. Great environment - warm & welcoming! They make ring shopping feel comfortable. Devon also sized my ring from a 7 to a 4.5 in 2 hours! Highly recommend!
Loved working with Devon here. Everyone was very nice and helped us through the ring buying process, especially since we ordered one off the website. Has many different stone selections too that help us stay within our budget.


Please feel free to contact us.

We have jewelry professionals ready to help.

Contact Us Appointment