Tuesday & Friday

10:00AM - 6:00PM

Sunday & Monday


Wednesday & Thursday

10:00AM - 7:00PM


10:00AM - 5:00PM

Virtual Appointments Available

We will be closed July 4th

About Worthington Jewelers


Worthington Jewelers Exterior

Since 2000, Worthington Jewelers in Columbus has offered one-of-a-kind jewelry creations to celebrate once-in-a-lifetime events. Family owned and operated, Worthington Jewelers was created to give central Ohio customers a source for high quality, yet affordable, jewelry. Committed to customer education, we’ll help you make informed decisions about the metals, diamonds, and gemstones used in making your jewelry.

As your personal jeweler, we’re also here to maintain your fine jewelry for a lifetime of enjoyment! Jewelry cleaning and inspections are always free, and we offer a full range of repair and appraisal services.

Engaged in the local community, Worthington Jewelers supports area schools, arts organizations, and other community groups. We are members of the Worthington Area Chamber of Commerce and the Old Worthington Partnership.

Worthington Jewelers is committed to the highest professional standards. We are members of the Jewelers of America and the Independent Jewelers Organization and are listed with the Jewelers Board of Trade. We offer one of the best lifetime transferrable warranties in the industry through Preferred Jewelers International. We also hold a Precious Metals Dealers License from the State of Ohio.

Child and dog-friendly, Worthington Jewelers offers a relaxed and enjoyable shopping environment. We hope you’ll stop by soon to learn what has made us the most trusted, best-reviewed jewelers in central Ohio! Read our online reviews to see why so many love shopping at our family-owned store!


Management Team

We want you to feel at home when you walk into Worthington Jewelers. On any given day you’ll find Bob, Theresa or other family member on the floor, ready to help you. Our niece Kathryn Givens manages the sales floor. Longtime employee Beth Bond manages operations. You’ll also be greeted by more than a dozen non-commissioned jewelry consultants, designers, managers, gemologists, and goldsmiths. (Also known as our extended family!)

Meet Bob & Theresa

Bob and Theresa

Romance is a professional and personal passion for Bob and Theresa Capace, owners of Worthington Jewelers. With five children and four grandchildren, the couple knows how important it is to celebrate one another and the bonds of family.

“I love the symbolism of engagement and wedding rings,” Theresa says. “It’s always been a thrill to help couples find the perfect expression of their relationship.”

Bob and Theresa believe that finding the right rings takes time, so they’ve created a relaxing place for you to shop and learn about diamonds as well as jewelry. “From the moment you step into our store, you’ll be treated as an honored guest,” Bob says. “We never want anyone to feel pressured. Our goal is to teach you enough about diamonds and jewelry to feel comfortable with your decision.”

As entrepreneurs who have raised five children, the couple has lots of budgeting experience. “Our focus is on delivering more bang for your buck,” Theresa says.

The Capaces ultimately strive to be a local resource. “Even if you just need a complimentary jewelry cleaning, we’re happy to be of service,” Theresa says. “Stop in and see us!”


Worthington Jewelers creates and sells jewelry you’ll treasure for a lifetime. Family owned by Bob and Theresa Capace, we offer a comfortable place for you to shop and learn about fine jewelry. Stop in to browse, ask questions, or simply fantasize. Our friendly, non-commissioned consultants are at your service.

No matter what your jewelry needs, we’re here to guide you in choosing diamonds, colored gems, and settings to fulfill your dreams at prices that fit your budget. We specialize in:

Engagement and Wedding Rings – Begin your lives together with one-of-a-kind engagement rings and wedding bands designed just for you. Or, choose from over 1,300 rings in central Ohio’s largest selection of bridal jewelry.

Fashion Jewelry – Looking for jewelry that’s just your style? Shop our exclusive designs in silver and gold.

Custom Designs – Work with our designers and goldsmiths to create one-of-a-kind rings, pendants, earrings, and more. Our selection is limited only by your imagination, thanks to our custom design capabilities.

Estate Jewelry – Love vintage? Check out our estate collection, or let us help you find that special piece you’ve been looking for.

Repairs and Appraisals – We’re here to help protect your jewelry investment with on-site repair and appraisal services.

Transforming Old into New – We’re happy to buy your unwanted and broken jewelry. Or, we can transform unwearable items into new, heirloom-quality designs.

At Worthington Jewelers, you’ll enjoy a friendly, relaxing environment for choosing jewelry to celebrate life’s most cherished moments. Come on in wearing jeans or even your sweats. Bring the kids and the dog, too. Above all, we’ll be happy just to see you. Visit our historic showroom on the Village Green in Old Worthington today!

  • Interior to Rear to Front Door
  • Exterior During Holidays


As part of our goal to give back, we support Worthington Schools, the Worthington Area Chamber of Commerce and the Old Worthington Partnership. We also contribute to a variety of local causes that we’re passionate about, including:

You’ll meet Bob and Theresa at many local fundraising events and on the Buckeye Cruise for Cancer.

Bob and Theresa also play an active role in central Ohio organizations such as the Columbus Italian Club and the GetDot networking group.

Without the support of the local community, we never would have made it this far. Bob, Theresa, and our team of jewelry consultants, goldsmiths and gemologists thank you for standing by us through the years and helping us grow. We look forward to what we can create together in the years to come.

  • Fire Chief
  • Giving Back GetDot