Sell Your Diamonds, Gold and Jewelry in Columbus
at Worthington Jewelers

Looking for a place to sell your diamonds, gold and jewelry in Columbus Ohio?

Come to Worthington Jewelers! When you visit our store at 692 High Street, you’ll find it’s more convenient than ever to sell your gold, silver, platinum and diamonds in Columbus. And you’ll get paid on the spot.

At Columbus Ohio’s trusted jeweler, you’ll work with a team of jewelry professionals to sell your diamonds and gold. Family-owned Worthington Jewelers is recognized as one of the top places to sell gold in Columbus. We are licensed as a precious metals dealer by the State of Ohio. An accredited member of the Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating, we also have been highly rated by customers on Angie’s List, Yelp!, Google and other review sites.


How Our Columbus, Ohio Gold Buying Service Works

  • At Worthington Jewelers, you don’t need an appointment to sell your old or broken jewelry.
  • Our staff will examine your jewelry, sort it by metal stamp (10k, 14k, 18k, platinum, sterling silver) and evaluate your diamonds and select gemstones.
  • Jewelry professionals will accurately test the karat content in your gold jewelry that is not stamped.
  • We weigh your items on the sales floor using certified scales.
  • You’ll receive an offer for your jewelry based on the day’s gold market.
  • The decision to sell is always up to you. If you accept our offer, you’ll be paid immediately.

We Buy Gold, Diamonds, Jewelry
and More

Here are some of the items we buy in Columbus every day:

  • Precious metal jewelry, including 10k, 14k, 18, 22 and 24k gold, silver and platinum.
  • Diamonds and other valuable gemstones including rubies, sapphires and emeralds. (If you have certification from a professional gemological laboratory such as GIA or EGL, please bring the certificate with you).
  • Gold and silver coins.
  • Sterling silver flatware, coffee and tea services, cups, mugs, bowls, platters and other serving pieces.
  • Dental gold.
  • Vintage pocket and wrist watches with gold and platinum cases.
  • Fine watches such as Rolex and Cartier.
  • Our Columbus Ohio gold buying service includes many unique items made of gold, silver and other precious metals. Bring in your item today for a complimentary evaluation.

10 Great Reasons to Bring Your Jewelry
to Worthington Jewelers

  • 10. We buy your jewelry based on the value of each item (including gemstones, if applicable).
  • 9.  We want your fine jewelry to resell. Check out our large estate jewelry selection.
  • 8.  Our location is in a safe and convenient neighborhood in downtown Worthington, Ohio.
  • 7.  Our scales are certified by the State of Ohio for accuracy.
  • 6. We are active members of IJO (Independent Jewelers Association).
  • 5. No high pressure tactics from our staff. The decision is yours. We will even clean your jewelry for you at no charge.
  • 4. Get 50 percent more for your gold and diamonds in trade for other jewelry items or repair services.
  • 3. We can use your diamonds and gemstones to remake or create a new piece of jewelry.
  • 2. If you choose to repair your item, we offer onsite jewelry repairs.
  • 1. We pay extremely competitive prices for gold, diamonds and other precious metals and select gemstones.