Absolutely amazing!

Worthington Jewelers does an amazing job of making sure you are educated on everything before you decide on what type of engagement ring and diamond you buy. Nancy Taylor did an amazing job with my fiancé and me to make sure we got exactly what we were looking for. They did a custom ring for us and it came out perfect the amount of time and energy Worthington Jewelers and Nancy did for my fiancé and I was amazing. We always recommend our friends and family go there anytime they need any jewelry.

JessAdams13
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

Bar none the best jeweler…

Bar none the best jeweler in Columbus Ohio! Staff is friendly as well as great owners!

Daniel G
Google

Click to see the full review.

Feel like part of the family!

We’ve gotten both our weddings bands and my engagement ring from Worthington jewelers, and we couldn’t be happier! They immediately made us feel comfortable at the store, and unlike other jewelry stores, weren’t pushy at all. Bob taught my fiance and I a lot about diamonds, gold, and other materials, so that we could make an educated choice in rings. We were given a very fair deal when it comes to price, and the staff, including Bill, are super friendly and eager to help. We can tell that everyone who works there is extremely knowledgable, and we feel confident that if there’s ever any issues with our rings, we can go back and we’ll be taken care of.

Thanks to Worthington Jewelers for making our wedding ring experience educational and fun. We will definitely be coming back for more jewelry in the future!

LoveBirdsFranks
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

Great service, great value!

We bought our bands here. Mine was simple white gold, very easy to pick out, but my husband had no idea what he wanted except that he wanted an alternative metal. In spite of the fact that we weren’t able to make it to the shop till about 40 minutes before they were going to close, the salesperson we worked with was very patient with us and took her time showing us the different alternative metals available, explaining their features, and helping us browse different styles. When my husband decided that he’d like one of the styles that was available in Cobalt but wanted the ring in Tungsten, two salespeople pored through catalogs to track down the closest design they could find available in Tungsten. Bottom line, we received great service, and we found rings we both love for a very reasonable price.

Eribibble
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

I stopped at this jeweler to get my engagement ring examined…

I stopped at this jeweler to get my engagement ring examined. It is an estate ring – it belonged to my fiancé’s great-grandmother – and one of the stones was loose. Afraid of losing it, I took it in to Worthington Jewelers. They did a fantastic job! It took them about a week to repair the ring, and it looks fantastic now! They were even able to rotate the center stone so that a chip that had been showing before is now hidden, and the ring gleams! The service is wonderful as well. All of the ladies who helped me were knowledgeable and very friendly. They told me exactly what I needed to know, and the price they gave me for the repair was very reasonable and affordable! They even polished my diamond necklace for free while I was waiting for them to come back with a price quote on the repair. This morning, I went to the bridal expo at the Convention Center in downtown Columbus, and I met with the owner. He is wonderful, and spent several minutes talking to my fiancé and me about what we wanted for our wedding rings, and gave us really great advice. I will definitely be taking my ring there for future repairs, and my fiancé and I will definitely be getting his wedding band there, if not mine as well. I am a very satisfied customer!

Allison Reeve
Google

Click to see the full review.

I was looking to sell some small golden pieces…

I was looking to sell some small golden pieces & a man named Mike really helped me out. There was no hassle, he got me in & out with a decent sum in a very professional manner. Mike is a kind & respectable man with impeccable skill. Five stars!

Wil D.
Yelp!

Click to see the full review.

My fiancé bought my BEAUTIFUL custom engagement ring…

My fiancé bought my BEAUTIFUL custom engagement ring from Worthington Jewelers. After he gave me the ring, he stated he would never go anywhere else for jewelry again. The customer service Barbara gave was exemplary, especially when the original diamond my fiancé wanted ended up being sold. Thank you for the amazing experience my fiancé had, and I can’t wait to come back to pick out our wedding bands!

Wedding Wire Reviewer

Click to see the full review.

My fiancé did an awesome job designing my engagement ring…

My fiancé did an awesome job designing my engagement ring with the help of the owners at Worthington Jewelers! I couldn’t be happier with how it turned out. We will definitely be getting my wedding band there! Thank you!

Alyssa Peterson
Facebook

Click to see the full review.

Such amazing service!

We received such amazing service when we went in to Worthington Jewelers. They helped us find the perfect engagement ring! We will definitely be going back for our wedding bands!

JSWheat06
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

We found the ONE

My fiancé and I began our ring search at Worthington since they are a local business and I’ve heard good reviews. We looked at few other jewelers but came back to Worthington because of the great service from Katherine and the uniqueness of the rings! We moved out of state recently after buying the ring and they shipped it to us! I absolutely LOVE the ring and we will be back to purchase our wedding bands as well!

GFlockem
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

We found the PERFECT rings!

My fiancé and I found our wedding bands at Worthington Jewelers. My engagement ring was also purchased there! We had so much fun looking around and the environment was so laid back and stress free! Our rings are so unique and definitely reflect our personal tastes, and the staff was so attentive to our wants and needs. With the huge selection of jewelry, there is most definitely a ring in there for everyone! My fiancé and I wanted to avoid buying our rings at an overrated, cliché jeweler so we instead opted to give our business to a local company we knew deserved it! You could spend hours in this store looking at all the fine jewelry they have to offer! I highly recommend Worthington Jewelers to find your perfect weddings rings that you’ll have for a lifetime! You seriously can’t go wrong!

Jen Schiefer
The Knot/Wedding Channel

Click to see the full review.

Worthington Jewelers was the best experience I had…

Worthington Jewelers was the best experience I had when looking at engagement rings. They were polite, friendly, and way more accommodating than all the other locations I looked at in the Columbus area. They also came off as very relaxed and generally trying to help instead of trying to make a sale. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy an engagement ring or jewelry.

DJ Maley
Google

Click to see the full review.

See all of our reviews, or leave one of your own, by visiting:

logo_the_knot

logo_wedding_wire

logo_yelp

logo_google

logo_angies_list